Dublin, Ireland

Ignisorigo

Honest guides for everyday decisions

Home › Home & Interior

Home & Interior

Why foam panels will not stop your neighbour's television

Soft furnishings tame echo but do little against a neighbour's bass. Working out which kind of noise you have decides which modest fixes are worth the effort.

Posted by Jonah Ibarra 4 min read

If air can get through, sound can get through.

That one sentence explains more disappointment in home soundproofing than any other. People hang thick curtains, stick foam tiles on a wall and lay a rug, and the neighbour's television is exactly as audible as before, because the sound was coming under the door and through the gap around a pipe the whole time.

Real sound insulation is building work: mass, separation and airtightness added to walls, floors and ceilings. Short of that, a good deal can still be improved, provided the effort goes where the noise actually travels.

First, identify the kind of noise

Airborne noise starts as sound in the air: voices, music, traffic, a barking dog. It gets in through gaps and through light, thin parts of the building such as hollow doors and single glazing. Impact noise starts as a knock on the structure itself: footsteps overhead, a chair scraped across a floor, a washing machine on spin. The structure carries it, and it comes out of your walls and ceiling as a thud.

A third thing gets confused with both. Echo, or reverberation, is the sound made inside your own room bouncing off hard surfaces. A room with bare floors and bare walls sounds loud and harsh even when little is coming in from outside.

Voices and television through a wallSeal gaps, add mass against the wall, check sockets and pipe holes
Noise from the corridor or stairwellDoor seals, a threshold strip, a heavier door
Traffic and street noiseWindow seals, secondary glazing, heavy lined curtains as a modest extra
Footsteps from aboveHas to be treated at the source: carpet and dense underlay upstairs. Little can be done from below without ceiling work
Your own footsteps bothering those belowThick rugs on dense underlay, felt pads, soft-soled slippers
Harsh, echoing roomsRugs, curtains, upholstered furniture, bookshelves, wall hangings
What helps with what

Close the gaps

This is the cheapest work with the clearest result. Turn off the lights in the hall and look at your front door from inside: wherever light shows around the edge, sound is coming in too. Fit compressible seals around the frame and a drop seal or brush strip along the bottom. A letterbox with an internal flap and brush helps more than its size suggests.

  • Run a bead of flexible acoustic sealant or decorator's caulk along the gap between skirting board and floor, and between skirting and wall, on the side facing the noise.
  • Seal around pipes where they pass through walls and floors, under sinks and behind radiators.
  • Look at window frames where they meet the wall, and at any trickle vents. Acoustic versions of vents exist, which is better than blocking ventilation.
  • Notice sockets set back to back in a shared wall. They can be a direct weak point. Sealing behind them is a job for an electrician, but it is worth knowing to ask.

Add mass where it counts

Heavy things block sound and light things do not. That is the whole reason a foam tile, which weighs almost nothing, has no useful effect on noise passing through a wall. Foam and other soft, porous materials absorb reflections within a room. They are for echo.

What a renter or a reluctant renovator can do is put weight against the offending wall. A fully loaded bookcase covering most of a shared wall, pushed tight to it, adds real mass plus an irregular surface. A fitted wardrobe full of clothes does much the same. Neither will silence a determined bass line, since low frequencies pass through all but the heaviest construction, but both take the edge off speech and television.

Doors are often the weakest part of a room. A hollow internal door is two thin skins over a cardboard core. Swapping it for a solid one, properly sealed, makes a bedroom noticeably quieter. For windows, secondary glazing with a generous air gap between the panes outperforms most other single measures against street noise, and removable versions exist for tenants.

Deal with impact and vibration at the source

Impact noise is best stopped before it enters the structure. Under your own feet that means a thick rug over dense felt or rubber underlay in the places people walk most, and felt pads under every chair leg. Stand a washing machine level on all four feet, since most spin-cycle thumping is a machine rocking on three, and consider anti-vibration pads beneath it. Move speakers and subwoofers off the floor and away from shared walls, on stands or isolation pads, and the neighbours will hear far less for the same volume in your room.

When the impact noise is somebody else's, the same remedies apply but on their side of the ceiling. This is where a calm conversation does more than any product. Most people have no idea how their footsteps or their late washing cycle sound below. Describe what you hear and when, ask instead of accusing, and suggest something specific such as a rug in the hall or moving the spin cycle earlier.

What is left over

Some noise will remain, and the last tool is masking. A steady, featureless sound such as a fan or a white or pink noise source raises the background level slightly, so that intermittent sounds stand out less and are less likely to wake you. Put the bed against the quietest wall, which is rarely the one shared with a neighbour's living room or the one facing the street. If the noise is severe, constant, and unmoved by any of this, the fix is in the building fabric, and an acoustic specialist can say what would work before money is spent on guesses.

  • noise
  • soundproofing
  • apartment living
  • comfort
  • neighbours
Jonah Ibarra Features Editor

Jonah writes about the practical end of home & interior, and tests everything before writing about it.